Go to Publicity
«Back to news

News

11.07.2017 - 00: 03

The reaction of the world media: the meeting of the presidents of Russia and the United States at the G20 summit

USA

The Washington Post: "President Donald Trump on Sunday tried to leave in the past statements about Russia's interference in the elections in the US in 2016, essentially rejecting the importance of unambiguous conclusion of the (American) intelligence community about the actions of a foreign enemy in order to establish partnership and cooperation with President Vladimir Putin. The first public commentary after talks with Putin in Germany, Trump vowed "to move forward in constructive work with Russia."

Newspaper Politico:"The meeting of the two presidents ended in a stunning victory for Vladimir Putin, and Donald Trump provided him with this victory." In a word and deed, the US president signaled his readiness to adjust to the outlook of Vladimir Putin and took steps in this direction.He almost fully supported the picture of events that he scrupulously builds The Russian leader. "

The New York Times: "President Trump, during his first meeting face to face with President Putin, raised the issue of Moscow's interference in the election of 2016, but, as American officials said, quickly moved on to the question of how the parties could work together, including in The field of countering cyberattacks and the de-escalation of war in Syria. The meeting between Putin and Trump put the rest of the agenda for the G-20 summit in the background and was viewed as potentially dangerous for the US president, who is being harassed by questions about collusion with the Russians during the election campaign. However, strangely enough, the talks with Putin turned into a favorable event for Trump on the first day of the G20 summit, where the US found itself in increased isolation from other participants in the meeting on issues such as climate change, immigration and trade. "

The Wall Street Journal: "President Trump began his first meeting with President Putin with concern about Russia's intervention in the US elections," Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said, emphasizing that Putin denied any interference. During the meeting with journalists, Tillerson noted that the ceasefire agreement in the southwestern regions of Syria that comes into force serves as the first indication that the United States and Russia are able to interact. Officials from Jordan and Israel - countries bordering on the south-western regions of Syria - also took part in the US-Russian negotiations. According to Tillerson, Trump wants Russia to commit itself not to intervene again in the affairs of the US or other countries. At the same time, he noted that Trump spoke with Putin about how both sides could move forward in the light of differences over interference in the elections. "

Broadcaster CNN:"Presidents Trump and Putin seem to have made some progress in overcoming disagreements on some issues, but it is too early to talk about success and announce the cessation of hostility that has been a feature of recent US-Russian relations. President Trump did more than expected, raising at the meeting the question of Russia's interference in US elections. Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov was reportedly told Russian journalists that Putin denied any interference and that Trump accepted the statement. Secretary of State Tillerson had a fundamentally different version of the conversation: he said that both sides could not agree on this issue. As for Putin, for him, the current meeting was an even greater success. Most of all, Putin wants to be considered an influential player on the world stage, and he has achieved this. And before the current meeting with Trump, Putin had reasons to be satisfied with the course of events. Although the US has not lifted sanctions against Russia, which is one of Putin's top priorities, he can happily observe what happens in the West after Trump comes to power. In the Western alliance, deep disagreements arose, and it was weakened. The United States and its Western European partners no longer adhere to common positions on key issues. "

ТFox:"The meeting took place in a situation where Trump changed the nature of his statements and took a tougher stance against Russia." Since joining the presidency, Trump's enthusiasm for establishing relations with Russia has been significantly extinguished and he criticized Russia for her support of Syrian President Bashar Assad The US also aroused Moscow's displeasure by agreeing to sell the Patriot missile defense system to Poland, and in a speech in Warsaw Trump criticized Russia for subversive activities around the world. "

Broadcaster ABC: "Russia and the United States said that the first meeting between Presidents Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin at the G-20 summit in Germany was successful, but after a few hours the White House had to defend Trump from criticism because he was accused of being soft in dealing with Putin, it seems that the Kremlin has bypassed the US administration in regard to the interpretation (outcome) of the meeting. "

Bloomberg Agency:"It is likely that President Putin was going to the first meeting with President Trump with the desire to provide him with something that could be demonstrated to the American audience and report it to Twitter. Putin gave him this opportunity. The ceasefire agreement in southwestern Syria is the headline for 140 signs that Trump can use as evidence that his idea of ​​closer interaction with Putin's government begins to yield results ... Trump seems ready to move on, leaving behind a dispute over Russia's intervention in the presidential election of 2016 ... Former US ambassador to Russia, Michael McFaul, stated that the meeting was "obviously not a moment of triumph" for Trump, since nothing was achieved except for the ceasefire agreement (in Syria). According to him, the approach to the problem of interference in the election campaign "is troubling." "It's no surprise that the Democrats proclaimed the meeting a failure without delay," McFaul said. "

Forbes Magazine:"At first glance, it seems that the meeting demonstrated the readiness of the two leaders to achieve practical results on the basis of outwardly friendly ties between them. However, despite the statements of both sides that the meeting went well, it is obvious that they do not trust each other ... From Russia's point of view, cooperation with the United States is based not only on assurances of friendship, but also on concluding various agreements that take into account the interests of Moscow. This includes the recognition of Russia's right to have all the advantages of a great power, for example, to preserve its sphere of influence in the post-Soviet space, treating it as an equal or having the right and duty to take decisions on key issues on the international agenda. During his presidential term, Obama understood this, and the relationship went into a conflictual plane. Probably, when Trump realizes what Russia's demands are, he will follow Obama's path and renounce friendly rhetoric ... Trump will also understand that Putin, unlike him, is a person who prefers decisive action, not talk. "

Germany

Deutsche Welle:"Meetings of the world's boxing stars, such as Wladimir Klitschko and Tyson Fury, attract the attention of a multimillion audience. However, the excitement around the fight in the ring fades in comparison with the excitement around the first meeting of two global political players - Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump. Will Putin grow pale during the strong handshake of Trump? Will Trump be able to endure Putin's cold look? Which one of them will fall first on his knees? Everyone who expected a sensation was disappointed - the meeting was like clockwork. The excitement around her may have been excessive, but the rapprochement between Trump and Putin, no matter how superficial it may seem, may give impetus to building constructive relations. "

The newspaper Die Zeit:"The meeting could be a new beginning, as evidenced by the rapprochement with Russia on the Syrian issue, the US side said.When the talks were still going on, it became known that the United States and Russia are preparing a truce for southwestern Syria.Although everyone was looking forward with great impatience to this moment, He did not bring full clarity.The questions remain, and everyone will just as closely observe the next steps, as well as behind this flirtation on the margins of the summit. "

Newspaper Handelsblatt:"The first meeting between Trump and Putin gives rise to a hope for detente in the relations between the superpowers, but the conflict between the two countries is in no way regulated." While the Secretary of State (Tillerson) said that Trump clearly told Putin about the intervention of Russian hackers in the election race in USA, his colleague Sergei Lavrov presented this topic in a different light. "

Newspaper Saechsische Zeitung:"The truly tangible result of the summit was reached only in its fields ... The agreement on a partial armistice in Syria inspires, at least, a cautious hope that both superpowers will now together try to put an end to the tragedy."

United Kingdom

The Independent:"The leaders of the United States and Russia together declared their political victory after their first meeting. On it, the parties, apparently, agreed on a potentially meaningful truce in the territory of part of Syria. This was a surprise that few people predicted. The Trump administration stated that from the very beginning of the meeting, which lasted 2 hours 16 minutes, the US president exerted pressure on Vladimir Putin during the "very lively and prolonged" exchange of views on the alleged interference of the Russian Federation in the US elections. Despite the different versions of the long-awaited meeting between the leaders of the two countries with the largest nuclear arsenal in the world, the parties seem to have managed to work out something of real value - a truce in the south-west of Syria, guaranteed by Russia, the United States and Jordan. "

Newspaper The Guardian:"The general attention to the meeting between Trump and Putin angered Germany, the country that hosted the G20 summit, and carefully designed its own program for the G20 during the year." During the first day, there were skirmishes between German Chancellor Angela Merkel and Trump about climate change, then Time as the EU threatened immediate response sanctions against the United States, if they implement their plans to introduce new tariffs for steel imports. "

France

Newspaper Le Figaro: "After a harsh exchange of views over allegations of Russian interference in the presidential elections in the United States, two leaders found" positive alchemy "in numerous files, especially in Syria ... Neither Donald Trump nor Vladimir Putin wanted to conclude a statement of disagreements ".

The newspaper Le Mond:"It's hard to say, especially given Trump's unpredictability, whether this meeting was a turning point and what it will bring to US-Russian relations in the coming months." The days when candidate Trump praised Mr. Putin (the "strong man I admire") have passed. Over the past months, President Trump has toughened his tone towards Moscow, including to make him forget about the constant accusations of his team's links to the Kremlin, and about Russian interference in the election campaign of 2016. "

Italy

The newspaper La Stampa:"Putin and Trump eventually managed to avoid macho rivalries, discussing more how to restore relations. However, many unknowns remain on the way to success in achieving this goal. In order to really understand and interpret this first meeting of the two leaders, it is first of all necessary to take into account Putin's strategy and tasks, which comes from the unpredictability and political zigzags of Trump, trying to turn them in his favor. Putin knows perfectly well what pressure Trump is exposed at home and in the world, and offers himself as a reliable partner, but not too compliant. In general, everyone was himself: Putin, as always, confident, Trump, as always, ready to change the line, following his instinct. "

Newspaper Corriere della sera:"From the point of view of the characters and the sympathy of the two real men, the summit summit between Putin and Trump was a good start. Of course, this discussion, which lasted much longer than the time that was envisaged by the protocol, was not without acute issues. But for Putin, its result is rather positive. In addition, the Russian leader secured respect and due regard for Russia, which he brought to the rank of global player. From the White House's point of view, the main political and media burden of this visit of Trump to Europe was the stop in Warsaw (before the G20 summit) and the meeting with Vladimir Putin "on the sidelines" of the summit. Everything else to the president (Trump) was undoubtedly boring. "

Spain

The newspaper El Pais:"In physics, magnetism is a natural phenomenon, because of which objects are attracted to each other. In politics, where it is increasingly difficult, this is exactly what happened between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. The US President is fascinated by the Russian leader. Such an attraction, like that of electric charges, caused him (Trump) to hold a meeting that his advisers were not strongly advised to arrange. Syria, North Korea, Ukraine, or the same sanctions against Moscow are issues that deserve more than one meeting. Putin has nothing to lose, unlike Trump. For the Russian side, an agreement on the establishment of a de-escalation zone in south-western Syria is a huge diplomatic success. "

Sweden

Newspaper Dagens Nyheter: "For Putin, the meeting can be considered another successful episode from the point of view of the image." As for Trump, it is unclear what exactly he wants from friendly relations with the Russian leader ... Trump, consistently trying not to speak ill of personally about Putin, The time of the visit to Poland before the G20 summit criticized the role of Russia in the conflict in the east of Ukraine. "

Newspaper Aftonbladet: "It seems that Putin insisted on a closed meeting, which gave him a clear advantage." Along with his foreign minister, Sergey Lavrov, he has many years of diplomatic experience, while Trump and his secretary of state Rex Tillerson are new to the case. "

Norway

Newspaper Aftenposten:"Well first of all, the leaders of the United States and Russia are engaged in a dialogue." If the US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is to be trusted, then at the personal level, there was a positive "chemical reaction." This reduces the risk of misunderstanding and contributes to the consolidation of peace. "

Newspaper Dagbladet:"It was important for Trump to hold the meeting in a positive way and preferably with a specific agenda." It seems that he got what he wanted. "He also raised the question of Russia's interference in the US elections, and it's a big plus for him. Equal to America's partners at the G20 summit, during which his meeting with Trump would have kept the press's attention to himself, with which the President has a strained relationship. "

Finland

Yle TV Company: "Expectations from the results of the first meeting between Putin and Trump were not high. None of the parties before the meeting reported on the issues that will be considered on it - it was characterized simply as an acquaintance of the heads of state. Therefore, it was simply enough for Russia to avoid a public quarrel. This alone has shown that the countries have intentions to normalize relations ... Although the Kremlin was offended by how Trump met virtually all the world's leaders before meeting Putin, Moscow did not blame Trump for this delay. Behind all is the "hysterical campaign against the Russians" launched by the enemy Trump. So even the very fact of a bilateral meeting of presidents the Kremlin regards as its victory. For Russia, its meaning was primarily in strengthening its own position in the new multipolar world, both in the eyes of its citizens and in the eyes of the rest of the world. The meeting that finally took place is a confirmation that the Russian Federation is solving world conflicts in cooperation with the United States and on an equal basis. "

Poland

Newspaper Rzeczpospolita:"The first meeting between the presidents of Russia and the United States took place in an atmosphere of courtesy, but all points to the fact that Donald Trump did not go into conversation with Vladimir Putin for any concessions that Poland and other countries in the region should be worried about. There was nothing left of the plans for the construction of a new world, which during the electoral campaign and immediately after the inauguration of the president was voiced by Trump, plans that some associated with the creation of new zones of influence, with the new Yalta. A few months ago, we worried that in exchange for Russia's contribution to the struggle in Syria with the Islamic state group (banned in Russia), Trump would allow the Kremlin to control Ukraine and a political deal would be concluded on this subject. During the talks on Friday, Ukraine was mentioned only in passing. "

Japan

NHK TV channel:"During the first personal meeting at the G20 summit, the Presidents of the United States and Russia agreed to establish a de-escalation zone in southern Syria and also decided to look for ways to improve bilateral relations, which, according to some estimates, are now at one of the lowest levels since the Cold War. However, as for the relations between Moscow and Washington, it is still unclear whether there will be any progress after this meeting, since the investigation of the Trump administration's relations with the Russian Federation continues in the United States. "

Kyodo Agency:"It seems that the restoration of the cooled relationship has been achieved, but the investigation of the US authorities casts a dense shadow on these relations, which creates obstacles to the normalization of ties." Putin had serious expectations related to Trump's coming to power, but the situation with the investigation into Election strengthened anti-Russian rhetoric. "

Newspaper Mainichi shimbun:"Unlike his predecessor (Barack Obama), who tried to solve problems in a group of states, Trump prefers to stake on personal contacts, so this time he was interested in separate meetings, and not the G20 summit itself. As for the outcome of the meeting between Trump and Putin, in fact, the conflict in the southwestern part of Syria is not so intense, and the cease-fire there is only the fact that such an agreement was reached at the business level. At the same time, it is absolutely incomprehensible how to come to peace in Syria and solve the main contradiction, that the Russian Federation supports Assad, and the US supports the opposition, which is against Assad. The situation in relations between Russia and the United States is now such that there is no other option how to look for ways of cooperation, based on those actions that can be carried out relentlessly. "

China

Xinhua Agency: "The first personal meeting between the presidents of the United States and Russia is encouraging, as it sends a positive signal in the field of bilateral relations. As permanent members of the UN Security Council, Washington and Moscow are heavyweights on the world stage. A healthy and stable relationship between them favors peace and stability throughout the world ... The geopolitical confrontation that has clouded relations between Russia and America for decades can not be eliminated. The current ice relationship is too bad to be defrosted in a day or two. However, the progress achieved recently shows the will, wisdom and courage of both sides to improve relations. The meeting between Putin and Trump demonstrates that they are ready to use the moment and move forward. "

ГAzeta Global Times:"Trump withstood the strongest pressure over his possible meeting with Putin, which indicated the difference between his policies and the policies of Barack Obama.It is unusual that for a long time there was no official meeting between the leaders of the United States and Russia.As one of the most important in world politics, These relations are of particular importance for global peace and security.The two countries have common interests and should cooperate on a number of the most pressing problems, such as the fight against terrorism and the Syrian question. "

Республика Корея

Yonhap Agency:"Following the talks between the leaders of the United States and Russia, US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said that the freeze of North Korea's nuclear program is unacceptable, since it has already made significant progress. In this regard, Washington believes that a complete cessation of the North Korean program is necessary. Thus, the United States rejected the earlier proposal by Russia and China to suspend the missile and nuclear programs of the DPRK and the joint exercises of the US and South Korean armed forces. This initiative was put forward by Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping following the summit in Moscow. At the meeting of the leaders of G20, Putin and Trump held a constructive exchange of views on the problem of North Korea, but the talks revealed a different approach of the parties to its solution. "

Australia

The Australian:"The meeting in Hamburg showed that Trump's political principle" America first "undermines US power and influence in the world. Moreover, in the future, his (Trump) will be replayed by Xi Jinping with the policy of "China before this" and Vladimir Putin with the policy "Russia first", because both are professionals in this game, and Trump is just an amateur. The summit demonstrated that America does not seem to have any coherent strategy for key global problems. Trump, apparently, feels that he needs to win over other countries, but he can not do it. At the same time, the confidence with which China and Russia treat him is alarming. The Russians have reasons to be satisfied. They came to the summit of G20 with the strategy of establishing a working dialogue with Trump, and they got such a dialogue. Trump called his first meeting with Putin "stunning." Putin really wants the US president to treat him as an equal in power, and, perhaps, he achieved it. Trump sees himself as a leader who can make effective deals, but his opponents - Putin and Xi Jinping - belong to this class of players he has not met before, although their countries do not have the same power as the United States. "

Mexico

Newspaper Universal:"As a person, as a politician and as an entrepreneur, Donald Trump is not disposed to give compliments to anyone. The only exception for one and a half years, since the presidential campaign in the United States began, was Russian President Vladimir Putin. For reasons, many of which remain a mystery, he is genuinely fascinated by the Russian leader. This feeling can be caused by an authentic admiration for Putin's courage and strategic thinking, but it may also be due to the fact that he pays for some important debt of honor ... After the first personal contact between Putin and Trump, it became obvious that a good relationship had been established between the two leaders and that Trump continued to demonstrate his admiration for Putin. When appearing in public, an American behaved particularly warmly and attentively towards his Russian counterpart. This contrasts markedly with the coldness and arrogance shown in the course of communication with other heads of state, for example, with the Chancellor of Germany, the leaders of the PRC or Mexico. Politically, it seems that Trump is really convinced that good relations between the US and Russia are a very important factor for maintaining peace and stability on the planet. "

Brazil

Newspaper Folha de Sao Paulo:"Let it not be a knockout, which, incidentally, is difficult to achieve during such meetings, but Vladimir Putin scored a convincing victory on points during his first meeting with Donald Trump. Of course, this is only something that can be distinguished from the first reports of negotiations. In the hall were two leaders, foreign ministers and translators, so the whole truth will only be known after a while. As for the current surface layer of facts, the controversial stories (about the discussion) of the complex topic of Moscow's interference in the US elections do not speak in favor of Trump ... Sign language was also favorable for Putin. The Russian leader barely looked into the face of the American during the first welcoming words, and not a single muscle on his face faltered when Trump called the "honor" the opportunity to attend the meeting. Finally, the handshakes were strong, but short-lived, to avoid new embarrassments for the representative of the Republican Party. "

Al Arabiya TV channel:"Was it coincidence that the wife of US President Donald Trump - Melanya at a dinner that was held during the G20 meeting, was sitting at a table next to Russian President Vladimir Putin? No one can answer this question, but the popular photos show a friendly, not friendly, The official atmosphere, which usually reigns during such "diplomatic feast".

Saudi Arabia

Newspaper Al-Sharq al-Awsat:"The importance of the meeting between Trump and Putin lies in the very dialogue between the US and Russia after a long period of deterioration in relations, for Trump this meeting is an opportunity to realize his election promise to improve relations with Moscow, Putin won the most, for Russia this is an opportunity to get out of the" cold winter hibernation "After economic sanctions and diplomatic isolation."

Lebanon

Newspaper Al-Akhbar:"The meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin helped the head of the White House, Donald Trump, get out of the isolation in which he was at the G-20 summit in Hamburg as a result of earlier rash steps and statements. Thanks to this meeting, Trump gained the status of a politician capable of negotiating with Russia, which is quite acceptable to the European partners of the United States. The truce in the south of Syria is the most important outcome of the talks between the Russian and American leaders. If this deal survives the test, then Moscow and Washington will convincingly demonstrate the effectiveness of their interaction. The fact that the US has gone to agreements involving the government in Damascus is Russia's diplomatic success. This exceptional moment can change the entire course of the conflict in Syria, as it opens the way for contacts through Russian intermediaries between Damascus and Washington. "

A source: Comte

Tags: Putin, Russia, Politics, USA, Trump, International Relations, Media, West, Europe